Many states reward 529 college-savings contributions with a state income tax deduction — but California is not one of them. This calculator makes that clear up front, then quantifies the benefit California savers actually get: completely tax-free investment growth in a ScholarShare 529 compared with a taxable account.
How it works
There is no California state deduction, so the value comes entirely from tax-free compounding. The tool projects a future-value annuity and compares it to a taxable account that loses some return to tax each year:
california state deduction = $0 (none offered)
529 future value = annual contribution compounded at r for n years (no tax drag)
taxable future value = same contributions compounded at r × (1 − taxRate) each year
federal benefit = 529 future value − taxable future value
The taxable path applies your marginal tax rate to the annual return as a
simple drag on compounding, which approximates the ongoing tax on dividends and
realized gains a non-529 account would incur.
Example
Contributing 5,000 a year for 15 years at a 6% return: the 529 grows
tax-free to about 123,300, while a taxable account taxed at a 24% effective
drag on returns grows to roughly 109,800. The tax-free advantage is about
13,500 — even with zero California state deduction.
Notes
California’s ScholarShare 529 has no state deduction, but earnings are federal-tax-free for qualified education expenses. Non-qualified earnings owe income tax plus a 10% federal penalty and a 2.5% California penalty. Recent rules also permit limited rollovers of unused funds into the beneficiary’s Roth IRA.